Serving since 1937 ISA Certified Arborists 24/7 Emergency Service • Call (208) 461-8733

Tree Damage Guide: Cracks, Hollows, Lightning & Uprooting

November 20, 2026
Tree Damage Guide

Tree damage falls into a handful of patterns, and each one tells you something different about whether the tree can stay. Our arborists at Parker Tree Service suggest triaging it in three passes: is anything in danger right now, what kind of injury is it, and can the tree heal, be supported, or does it have to come out?

Winter is when frost cracks and snow-load breakage start to show across the Treasure Valley. This guide walks through each pass so you know which signs of a damaged tree need a same-day call and which can wait for an arborist’s visit.

Step One: Decide Whether It Can Wait

Most damage gives you time to get an opinion. The question “is my tree going to fall” usually comes down to whether something is moving that wasn’t moving before. These signs call for a same-day response instead of a scheduled visit:

  • A tree or large limb resting on a roof, vehicle, fence or service line
  • A crack that opens and closes in the wind, or one you can see from both sides of the trunk
  • Soil heaving or cracking on one side of the base, especially under a new lean
  • A broken branch hung up in the canopy (arborists call these hangers)
  • Any contact with a power line. Stay well back and call the utility first.

If any of those apply, keep people and pets clear of anywhere the tree or limb could land, and use our 24/7 emergency tree service. For a large tree that has already failed or is leaning toward the house, our post on storm-damaged tree removal in Boise covers what happens next. Insurance claim questions are answered in our insurance guide for fallen trees.

Pro Tip: With a storm-damaged tree, what to do first is simple: photograph it from several angles before anyone touches it, including the base and any cracks. The photos show how a crack or lean changes over the following days.

Step Two: Identify the Type of Tree Damage

Once nobody is at risk, figure out what you’re looking at.

Cracks and Splits in the Trunk

Not every crack is a failure in progress. A frost crack is a vertical split that opens on a cold winter night, often on the south or southwest side. It may close and reopen for years while building a raised ridge of woundwood. Horizontal cracks across the grain, and splits running down from a branch union, are far more serious because the wood is already breaking.

Hollows and Cavities

A hollow trunk is not automatically dangerous. A cavity surrounded by a thick, sound shell can stand for decades. Arborists judge hollows by how much sound wood remains compared with the trunk’s radius, and by whether the cavity has an open side.

Damage typeWhat you’ll usually seeTypical urgencyCommon outcome
Frost crackVertical split, often on the sun side, may have a woundwood ridgeLow unless the crack is movingMonitor; usually keep
Split union or horizontal crackCrack at a fork or across the grain, fresh wood visibleHighBrace if the tree is otherwise sound; often remove
Hollow or cavityOpening in the trunk, fungal growth, hollow sound when tappedVaries with shell thicknessAssess; keep, reduce weight or remove
Lightning strikeBark stripped in a line or spiral, debris on the groundModerate; high if large pieces are looseRemove loose bark and hazards, then watch through a growing season
Tipped or uprootedNew lean, exposed roots, lifted soilHigh for mature treesRe-stand small trees; remove large ones

Lightning Strikes

Lightning usually leaves a strip of blown-off bark running down the trunk, sometimes in a spiral, with bark fragments scattered on the ground. The visible scar often understates the injury, because the current can also damage roots and inner wood.

Uprooted or Tipped Trees

Small, young trees that tip over in wet soil can sometimes be stood back up and staked, if most roots stay intact and the work happens quickly. A mature tree with a lifted root plate is a different problem and is rarely a candidate for re-standing.

Broken Limbs and Snow Load

Wet snow that arrives while trees still hold their leaves is a common cause of winter breakage. A clean break on a healthy limb can usually be pruned back to a proper cut, while bark torn down the trunk points to a bigger structural question. Getting trees ready before snow arrives is covered in our guide to preventing winter storm damage.

Step Three: Keep, Brace or Remove

Structural problems in trees are judged on more than the defect itself. ISA’s risk assessment method weighs the likelihood that a part fails, the likelihood it hits something, and the consequences if it does. A cracked limb over a pasture and the same limb over a bedroom are different risks. Our tree risk assessment service puts that judgment in writing.

The middle option is supplemental support. Under the ANSI A300 standard for supplemental support systems, cables installed high in the canopy and threaded rods through split or weak unions limit movement, so a sound tree with one weak point can stay. It won’t save a dying or badly decayed tree. Before any cabling and bracing service goes in, an arborist should check whether the wood will hold the hardware.

If…Then…
The tree is healthy and has one defect, such as a weak forkAsk about cabling or bracing paired with weight-reduction pruning.
The crack is old, closed and lined with woundwoodMark the crack ends with paint, date them, and recheck after each windy season.
Decay, a crack and a target all line upPlan for removal, and don’t wait for spring if the target is your house.
A small tree tipped in a stormRe-stand and stake it as soon as you can, before exposed roots dry out.
The Messy Middle: Telling an Old Wound From a New Failure The hardest call in damage triage is whether a defect is active. A crack stable for years and one that opened last night can look alike from the lawn. Up close, fresh wood is pale and clean, while old cracks are weathered gray with rolled woundwood edges. A good arborist gets close before deciding. That means a ladder or binoculars, sounding the trunk with a mallet, looking for fungal fruiting bodies near the base, and checking the root plate for soil cracks. When that still can’t settle it, the next step is a documented monitoring plan or a closer look at the inner wood. A guess either way, removing a sound tree or keeping a failing one, is the outcome to avoid.

The Bottom Line

  • Movement is the deciding signal: a crack, lean or root plate that is changing needs a same-day call.
  • Split unions and horizontal cracks are high risk. Bracing works only when the rest of the tree is sound.
  • Lightning-struck trees often get one growing season before a keep or remove decision.
  • Small tipped trees should be re-stood fast, ideally within a day or two, before exposed roots dry out. Mature uprooted trees almost always come down.

Schedule a Tree Damage Assessment

If your tree has cracked, hollowed, been struck or started to lean, one of our ISA Certified Arborists can sort out which category it’s in and what each option involves. Have an arborist triage the damage, and we’ll walk the tree with you.

About the Author

Parker Tree Service is a family-run tree care company founded in 1937 by George “Brownie” Parker. Justin Parker manages the Treasure Valley business from Caldwell, Idaho, and the team includes ISA Certified Arborists. The company is licensed, bonded, and insured (Licensed Contractor RCE #26718).

Years in the industry: In business since 1937.

Technical focus for this guide: Triage of structural tree damage, including cracks, cavities, lightning injury, and root plate failure, and the keep, brace or remove decision.

Professional profile: Parker Tree Service company history and team

Accessibility Toolbar